Episode 56
Becoming Edible: Aliveness, Death, and the Invisible Dimension with Dr. Andreas Weber
Andreas Weber has studied marine biology and cultural systems alongside his work with theoretical biologist Francisco Varela. Andreas has worked over the years on the concept of enlivenment and looking at the “biosphere as a meaning-creating and poetic reality”. This episode is about dissolving the boundaries of a mechanistic worldview and finding a new depth of meaning, reciprocity, and service. Becoming edible is the touchstone for the talk as Andreas walks us through ideas of reciprocal transformation of matter, what it might mean to surrender to impermanence and that transformation, and how death links us to the whole of life and aliveness. It is also about how we define language and mentorship in response to everything we take in from the interconnected web of life. Andreas guides us through how Western culture and civilization has strayed from so many of these concepts and the trauma that represents on concentric levels. Our chat is wrapped up by exploring the invisible dimension. This is a wide-ranging and beautiful deep dive into our felt experience of matter, of aliveness, of death, and beyond and is absolutely not to be missed.
Find Andreas:
Website: https://biologyofwonder.org/
Books:
The Biology of Wonder: Aliveness, Feeling, and the Metamorphoses of Science
Matter and Desire: an Erotic Ecology
Timestamps:
00:05:59: Old Salt Festival Shoutout
00:10:58: Interview Begins with a line from Rilke and some ruminations on poetry
00:21:08: Becoming Edible
00:28:48: The hard to define line between self and other
00:37:13: Reciprocal Transformation
00:43:05: Healing rifts of isolation
00:48:49: Surrendering to impermanence and transformation
00:58:31: Death links us to the whole
01:16:38: Non-meditation and finding mentors
01:36:51: Gift, culture, and trauma
01:46:02: The invisible dimension
Books + Resources Mentioned:
Letters to a Young Poet by Rainer Maria Rilke, translated by Joanna Macy
Duino Elegies by Rainer Maria Rilke
Philosophy of Baruch de Spinoza
Current Discounts for MBS listeners:
- 15% off Farm True ghee and body care products using code: KATEKAV15
- 20% off Home of Wool using code KATEKAVANAUGH for 10% off
- 15% off Bon Charge blue light blocking gear using code: MINDBODYSOIL15
Join the Ground Work Collective:
Find a Farm: nearhome.groundworkcollective.com
Find Kate: @kate_kavanaugh
More: groundworkcollective.com
Podcast disclaimer can be found by visiting: groundworkcollective.com/disclaimer
Transcript
Howdy.
Kate:I'm Kate Kavanaugh, and you're listening to the Mind, body and Soil Podcast where
Kate:we're laying the groundwork for our land, ourselves, and for generations to
Kate:come by looking at the way every threat of life is connected to one another.
Kate:Communities above ground mirror the communities below the soil, which
Kate:mirror the vast community of the cosmos.
Kate:As the saying goes, as above so below, join me as we take a curious journey
Kate:into agriculture, biology, history, spirituality, health, and so much more.
Kate:I can't wait to unearth all of these incredible topics alongside you.
Kate:Hello everyone and welcome to the Mind, body and Soil Podcast.
Kate:I am your host, Kate Kavanaugh, and I am coming to you in this intro from
Kate:Texas Hill Country after a weekend at the What Good Shall I Do Conference.
Kate:I am so excited to unpack more of my experiences here at the conference
Kate:for the podcast, and to release, I hope, the, the talk that I had the
Kate:privilege of giving this weekend.
Kate:But I am sitting here on a Monday just really deeply inspired about
Kate:what is possible when we find ourselves in relationship with
Kate:everything else in the world.
Kate:And it is with that, that I want to introduce this week's guest, uh,
Kate:Andreas Weber, who is an incredible, um, Andreas holds a, holds his
Kate:degrees in marine biology and cultural studies, and he collaborated with the
Kate:theoretical biologist, Francisco Varela, uh, before his, before his death.
Kate:And I found Andreas's work through another guest on this podcast, Brandy Stanley,
Kate:and really had one of those moments where you feel like you find a missing
Kate:puzzle piece in your life, something that begins to tie together everything
Kate:else and becomes a real keystone for the way that you move forward.
Kate:His book, biology of Wonder is amongst, uh, , my most favorite books that
Kate:I've ever read, as well as his book Matter and Desire and Erotic Ecology.
Kate:Andreas is an incredible thinker, and I think that he is synthesizing
Kate:a lot of information about the way that there is this mutual sharing of
Kate:matter and energy within ecosystems and within life, and that we can seek this
Kate:aliveness and this meaning creating and poetic reality as he calls it,
Kate:in every interaction that we have.
Kate:I was truly honored to sit down with Andreas.
Kate:It was a really special moment for me, and I think that the contents of this
Kate:podcast may just may just change the way that you think about life as well.
Kate:I highly recommend picking up Andreas's books and diving into his work because
Kate:I think that it really provides a counterpoint to the data-driven
Kate:work that I think a lot of us seek out and into a depth of feeling and
Kate:experiencing that we cannot forsake as part of our human experience of being
Kate:in this interconnected web of life.
Kate:I know that I myself have been seeking out a lot more, a lot more
Kate:in-person experiences and chances to truly find that basis for connection.
Kate:Um, both with the landscapes that I occupy and the friendships and the relationships
Kate:that I am building in this life.
Kate:I think that it's really easy to get caught up in the way that we couch
Kate:everything in economic productivity and our value as our output.
Kate:And I've been really curious as of late, just how I can find myself
Kate:in my relationship to even just the grass under my feet as I walk every
Kate:day in the pastures on the farm.
Kate:Sometimes it's walking up the hill right next to my house and just experiencing the
Kate:subtle shifts of the season where we are.
Kate:And everything comes on so fast that with each day there are more buds
Kate:on the trees, there are more insects to be found, more bird song to be
Kate:heard and to be a part of that.
Kate:Waking up that is happening in spring and that felt aliveness that
Kate:we can access at any given moment.
Kate:Andreas also has a beautiful course called The Ecology of Love.
Kate:I have linked to this as well as all of his books in the show notes, and
Kate:I'm hopeful that his next book becoming Edible will be translated into English.
Kate:We've also include included the translation of the poet Rka that Andreas
Kate:and I have an opportunity to discuss.
Kate:Before we dive into the podcast, I have a couple of housekeeping items, one of
Kate:which is a little announcement about the Old Salt Festival that will be happening
Kate:in Montana at the Mannox Ranch near Helm on June 23rd through the 25th.
Kate:I will actually be there, which I am so excited about.
Kate:I am going to have a chance to meet so many people that I haven't yet met.
Kate:There are going to be.
Kate:open cook fires with some incredible local beef and lamb and pork
Kate:with some incredible chefs there.
Kate:There's going to be live music.
Kate:There's going to be some speakers, including people that you've heard
Kate:on this podcast like Nicolette Naiman and Ed Roberson, Diana Rogers is gonna
Kate:be there, as well as Deborah Mag Pie, Erling, and some other incredible guests.
Kate:And I think that it is just going to be, like I just said, an incredible chance
Kate:to get to connect and experience some food and some conversation and some
Kate:aliveness, if you will, all together.
Kate:And there's a link for that in the show notes.
Kate:And I really hope that you're able to join me so that we can meet.
Kate:I know I got to meet so many of you over this weekend at the
Kate:What Good Shall I Do Conference?
Kate:And I'm just looking forward to, to more of that in-person connection,
Kate:more hugs, more handshakes, more eye contact, and I think this is going
Kate:to be a wonderful place to find that.
Kate:as we do many weeks.
Kate:I would love to read a review from the podcast.
Kate:Uh, these reviews are absolutely blowing me away and making me feel so honored
Kate:to be in this reciprocal space with you.
Kate:And as always, I like to offer that.
Kate:If you leave me a review on the podcast, take a snapshot and send
Kate:it to my Instagram or my email, kate groundwork collective.com.
Kate:I'd love to send you a little piece of snail mail so that we can connect
Kate:in this plane here in tangible ways.
Kate:And it's without further ado that I'm going to read this review from Pan
Kate:Lab that just, I'm really moved me for the curious heart and open mind.
Kate:. These long form interviews and conversations with Kate never feel forced.
Kate:They move freely from the practical and economic to the deeper
Kate:philosophical and spiritual aspects of living through this tipping point.
Kate:The questions are well thought out and require the guest to offer more
Kate:of themselves than is normally given.
Kate:Kate is an excellent interviewer and she offers a deep well of knowledge
Kate:and insight for the curious listener.
Kate:She is a kindred spirit for those of us that are seekers, always
Kate:questioning the answers we receive and the beliefs we internalize.
Kate:I was so grateful for this interview.
Kate:It was just too kind and really touched on.
Kate:I I really hoped to offer you a different view of the guests that
Kate:we have on this podcast and some of the aspects of their work.
Kate:And always, always, I want to be here for the seekers and
Kate:the questioners in this space.
Kate:So thank you so much Pan lad, and thank you to everybody that
Kate:has left a rating and a review.
Kate:It really helps others find and connect with this show
Kate:is my pleasure to produce it.
Kate:But, and, and I felt really in touch with this this weekend, I really want
Kate:to be able to share the incredible stories that I feel are unfolding in
Kate:the, in the recordings of these podcasts.
Kate:And these reviews really help others find some of that, that social proof that.
Kate:This podcast contains some really incredible stories because it
Kate:has just been my honor to tell these stories over the last year.
Kate:And they have transformed my life in ways that I never could have imagined.
Kate:And I hope that you are experiencing even just a little bit of the same.
Kate:Um, and I think that's it.
Kate:There are no more housekeeping items.
Kate:I hope to see you in Montana in June.
Kate:If I had the chance to hug you this weekend, it was such a pleasure and I
Kate:am really looking forward to putting this podcast with Andreas out into the
Kate:world and hearing what y'all thought.
Kate:If you've picked up his books, I know that I've mentioned
Kate:them in previous interviews.
Kate:I know it came up with our, in our interview with Katie Forrest, with Adrian
Kate:Grier, because I was just so, so inspired by his work these past few months.
Kate:So I'm just, I can't wait to hear what you think.
Kate:And without further ado, here is the incredible Andreas Weber.
Kate:Oh, it's just, it's just such a, you know, we, I was just telling you,
Kate:it's been such a pleasure to sort of immerse myself in your brain and I'm
Kate:excited to be in conversation and.
Kate:As I was considering how I might open this interview because I find the beginning of
Kate:things to always be the most difficult.
Kate:I actually wanted to let Rka ask the first question, and you so be,
Kate:you are so poetic yourself and you weave poetry throughout your work.
Kate:And so I thought that this might be a fitting space, and so
Kate:I'm gonna read a stanza and it ends in a, a bit of a question.
Kate:And so I thought we might, we might start there, especially as I
Andreas:considered this was great.
Andreas:I mean, that's not a, that's not an weird place at all.
Andreas:Lived with him.
Andreas:And actually I just, yesterday I had a conversation with some friends
Andreas:and colleagues over email about, um, some of his poetry and some,
Andreas:and his stance towards, um, reality.
Andreas:So, very good.
Andreas:It's just a continuing over from yesterday.
Andreas:. You see, I already have some repackaged thoughts for you on that.
Kate:Oh, I love that.
Kate:I love it.
Kate:When
Andreas:yesterday I, I, I prepared yesterday.
Andreas:Okay, go ahead.
Andreas:I love that.
Andreas:I'm curious, which, which poem?
Kate:Yeah, so I'm in, I'm in the middle of the second gy.
Kate:Mm-hmm.
Kate:And he says, for our part, when we feel we evaporate, uh, we breathe
Kate:ourselves out and away from ember to ember, we give off a fainter scent.
Kate:True.
Kate:Someone may tell us, you're in my blood this room, the
Kate:spring itself is full of you.
Kate:But why he can't hold us?
Kate:We vanish in and around him and the beautiful ones, ah, who holds them back,
Kate:appearance ceaselessly flares in their faces and vanishes, like do from the
Kate:morning grass with ours, rises from us the way heat lifts from a steaming dish.
Kate:Oh, smile going where?
Kate:Oh, upturned look new, warm, departing, surge of the heart.
Kate:Alas, we are the surge then does the cosmic space that
Kate:we dissolve in taste of us.
Kate:Hmm.
Kate:And I found a couple of different translations of that last question.
Kate:One being does the cosmic space that we dissolve in taste of us and the
Kate:second being does the outer space into which we dissolve taste of us at all?
Kate:Yeah.
Kate:And I'll throw the German in the chat for you in case you wanna Oh yeah.
Andreas:I, I was about to get up and get this book again, which
Andreas:got yesterday from my bookshelf.
Andreas:But if you have it, if you have it here, I, yeah.
Andreas:Okay.
Andreas:So
Kate:I won't embarrass both of us by trying to say it in German, but I put
Kate:that last question in German in the chat.
Andreas:Probably it's okay if it doesn't disrupt your, the recording.
Andreas:I'll just get up and get the book.
Andreas:Is that okay?
Kate:Yeah, absolutely.
Kate:Please.
Kate:No, not at all.
Andreas:I love that.
Andreas:You know, you know what I, I really, I really lived with those
Andreas:allergies for, for, for long years.
Andreas:And, um, so that's probably the most, it has been the most lived
Andreas:through part of Lucas's work.
Andreas:And then the allergies somehow faded and I went further into
Andreas:the last part of his work.
Andreas:The, the sonnet.
Andreas:Mm-hmm.
Andreas:. And, um, I'm, I'm dwelling more there at the moment.
Andreas:Just, just gimme a second.
Andreas:Yeah,
Kate:yeah.
Kate:Pull it up.
Kate:We have all the space in the world.
Andreas:Look
Kate:here we're, I have mine, which also has the German
Kate:. Andreas: Can you see my, it's from 1988
Kate:. Kate: 88.
Kate:I love the year I
Andreas:was born.
Andreas:That's one . Well that's, that's not by chance obviously.
Andreas:number.
Andreas:It's number two.
Andreas:Right?
Andreas:Number two.
Andreas:I really, I really, um, find that and, um, Okay, so where, where
Andreas:in number two is they're long.
Andreas:It's relatively like
Kate:it is.
Kate:So it's the third.
Kate:It's sort of the third part from the beginning.
Kate:Okay.
Kate:For our part,
Andreas:it starts
Andreas:Okay.
Andreas:Yes.
Andreas:Okay.
Andreas:Yeah.
Andreas:Well, absolutely . That would be my totally, yes.
Andreas:Totally.
Andreas:Only that, that the, the thing which, which, which somehow is not, um,
Andreas:um, space compatible whole, whole total, whole compatible is our personal ego.
Andreas:Which, which, which will dissolve and needs to dissolve.
Andreas:But that doesn't mean that our experience will dissolve and our
Andreas:being part of luminous, part of the luminous ground will dissolve.
Andreas:And I think he's talking about this, you know, he, he is such a profound mystic
Andreas:and what he's doing in his, in his late works is to, to describe this, um,
Andreas:this realization that, um, through the.
Andreas:The individual process of expression, of creation, of, of being poetic.
Andreas:The, the whole somehow realizes itself.
Andreas:And then again, all this is, um, dissolved in the whole, which is
Andreas:somehow the greatest achievement.
Andreas:This dissolution.
Andreas:And I could quote you another, more, more other poems, and, and
Andreas:oh my, to, to, to, um, to show you that, that he's really after this.
Andreas:And I, he wasn't understood at all.
Andreas:Looking back, he's not really one of the most celebrated poets in
Andreas:German, uh, culture at the moment.
Andreas:He is somehow under the suspicion of being, being a bit too romantic
Andreas:and not, not modern enough.
Andreas:And, um, so you, maybe this has, this is changing a little bit,
Andreas:but, um, um, but he, he was so, he was somehow misunderstood.
Andreas:It wasn't seen that he was actually really, really doing a
Andreas:profound spiritual work there.
Andreas:Who did see this was Joanna Macy, who, who, who, um, translated worker.
Andreas:And that's, I think it's the best English language translation.
Andreas:It's, it's not, she didn't do the rhymes, which is a bit
Andreas:difficult sometimes, but she.
Andreas:It's also, it leads you to, to weird constructions.
Andreas:If you want to let it rhymes all the time, wear it rhymes in the original language.
Andreas:So that's I, my, my preferred English language translation of work.
Andreas:And of course, as she's a Buddhist and she's, she's concerned with, um, life
Andreas:and ecology and, and the whole, um, he's, he's absolutely meaningful for her.
Andreas:Yeah.
Andreas:Great.
Andreas:Start this thought.
Andreas:. Kate: Good.
Andreas:This thought occurred to me as you put forth in our, in our email back and
Andreas:forth, the idea of becoming edible.
Andreas:And I think that your work is so fantastic at describing in so many ways
Andreas:this constant transformation of matter that is, that is underlying all of
Andreas:life at every given moment that we are experiencing these inter penetrations
Andreas:of matter turning into us and turning into us, turning into other, and
Andreas:dissolving into that, into that space.
Andreas:And I wanted to open there on that idea of this, of this constant
Andreas:and eternal transformation that is always, always happening.
Andreas:Yeah.
Andreas:Yeah, well, you said it very well and um, thank you for putting it that
Andreas:well, if, if you ask me, give me, give a little concise, um, statement
Andreas:about, about being edible, I wouldn't have been able to put it that Well,
Andreas:so, but I can elaborate on that.
Andreas:So, so, you know, it, it, it's, it totally makes sense to have started with real
Andreas:care, um, because he, what he was saying was, he was talking play just about this,
Andreas:you know, he was just, he was talking about life as constant dissolution into,
Andreas:into the all encompassing life and, and actually the, the process of creativity
Andreas:itself as being this dissolution, and again, meaning that if that happens
Andreas:like this, it also means that dissolving we find ourselves that that was, that
Andreas:was the, that's the the statement you, or the question you put into the chat.
Andreas:Does the, does the whole all encompassing space taste of us, and yes, it does,
Andreas:because this space is, it is the, the inner core of life actually.
Andreas:It is the living center and the living expansion and as our inner core is
Andreas:this, so Absolutely, of course it does.
Andreas:And people who pertaining to different.
Andreas:Spiritual or reg religious schools know about mystical experiences.
Andreas:They will all tell you the same.
Andreas:That by being able to step out of this limitation of the thinking ego,
Andreas:they, what they discover is home is themselves in completeness, in this all
Andreas:encompassing ocean of reality and not get back to getting, to being edible to
Andreas:make it a little bit more, um, concrete.
Andreas:So, so what I, what I, what I was, what I'm talking about when I use this term,
Andreas:which also will be the title of my next book, um, in, in German Esparza and
Andreas:hopefully then also in English at, at some point, is actually, um, that the,
Andreas:the fact that the living reality of the biosphere is just repeating this process
Andreas:of becoming aware that we are the whole reappearing in different individualities.
Andreas:I, I can say it like this now as I have realized that actually what I've
Andreas:been coming to from, from philosophy of Biology or from rethinking Biology
Andreas:and from the training with my.
Andreas:Teacher, Francisco Varela, um, about, um, living organisms as the desire
Andreas:to bring forth themselves as living centers is actually nothing else.
Andreas:It's nothing else.
Andreas:Then the realization that there is only one hole with all these little swirls
Andreas:and eddies, um, which then again, dissolve into the hole, which means
Andreas:that actually in these eddies it is the hole itself, which realizes itself.
Andreas:And, um, so, so every individual in a way is a manifestation
Andreas:of that and can go there.
Andreas:But the, the fascinating thing is that if you look at the, the empirical
Andreas:side of that, so on a, on a level below any form of experiential
Andreas:realization, it still holds.
Andreas:And that is fascinating.
Andreas:And, and it's interesting that that science who, which knows this cause
Andreas:what I use for this argument are, are bits of empirical science, of
Andreas:biology and of physics and chemistry and biochemistry and all these things.
Andreas:So it's nothing esoteric at all.
Andreas:It's not, no, not woo at all.
Andreas:But, but it's interesting that science or the scientists don't, are not
Andreas:really in this fact, So it's because it's somehow not on the agenda.
Andreas:And the agenda is much more about struggle for life between individuals.
Andreas:Um, which, which as we have seen are only transitory states in,
Andreas:in the dance of different phases of this encompassing whole.
Andreas:So it's, it's our culture who is not interested in this.
Andreas:Um, and with, with a lot of bad consequences because it's not
Andreas:interested in, let's say, in, in, in, in the aliveness, which
Andreas:is manifest in our reality.
Andreas:And so we are destroying it.
Andreas:But that's, that's another thought we might be talking about.
Andreas:And so it's actually not, it's not not even something particularly special.
Andreas:And when I'm talking of being edible as the fundamental feature of, uh,
Andreas:living beings, then I always, you, if you have looked at some material
Andreas:in the internet, you, you know this cuz I always, I always go there.
Andreas:I always go, come, come to breathing and eating.
Andreas:So it's actually very simple because what we do is when we eat, so we eat other
Andreas:beings who are edible, like, like us.
Andreas:So I, I had, as somebody who's spending months of his life every year in Italy, I
Andreas:had some pasta for, and um, . And so, so this, the, the grain in this is made from,
Andreas:mainly from carbon, carbon carbohydrates.
Andreas:And those become my body.
Andreas:And you, you see this, you see this in the, if you look at the
Andreas:chemical reaction, you can see this.
Andreas:And you, you have been taught this in school, I bet in, in whatever mid midterm
Andreas:biology or whatever it's called, like in, in seventh grade or eighth grade.
Andreas:You've learned this.
Andreas:And, and then still, we are not pointed to the fact that that through
Andreas:this transformation of the bodies of others into our own bodies, we are
Andreas:actually in a continuum of bodies being connected, like linked in a
Andreas:chain or, or a, or a string of pearls.
Andreas:And then we give our body away by breathing out.
Andreas:So that's the other, that's the next, the other, um, movement is that in the
Andreas:same central chemical reaction, circular reaction in every cell, um, we shed
Andreas:carbon and we breathe it out as co2 as we know, everybody breathe this out.
Andreas:Co2.
Andreas:So that's our body.
Andreas:So we are giving away our body and where does, does this body go?
Andreas:And I mean, now it becomes really, really interesting.
Andreas:This body is being eaten by the plant and it, it is made their body so that
Andreas:the carbon, which I breathe out right now, In this moment will go when I open
Andreas:the window, actually the windows are a bit leaky because it's an old flat.
Andreas:So actually it goes outside and it goes into the me too, into the
Andreas:Good for you.
Andreas:So you can, you can, you can share your body directly with
Andreas:the plant beings outside.
Andreas:Mm-hmm.
Andreas:, you know, and, um, I think this is, it's such a mystical insight and it's,
Andreas:it's, you know, it's, no, no, no.
Andreas:Not a single scientist would contradict you because it's,
Andreas:this is just what is happening.
Andreas:You could radioactively label it and it's just, but it's incredible.
Andreas:So obviously my identity is not the identity of my body.
Andreas:Cause my body is completely fluid.
Andreas:It's changing all over.
Andreas:And it's actually, my body is actually the, the weed's body.
Andreas:And, and then it's again the, the maple trees body.
Andreas:And as we all know, as the San girls, every, every ATO in
Andreas:ourselves once, just, just to make the link to the, to the space.
Andreas:El was talking about every adamant ourselves was once in the, in the
Andreas:center of a star, of an exploding star.
Andreas:You know?
Andreas:So we actually, all the matter in the universe is, is is somehow of the same
Andreas:source and going back to the same source.
Andreas:And, and we are just part in this transformation.
Andreas:So we are, we are very much at home in this, and we can
Andreas:only be exist through this.
Andreas:Which shows you like coming from this point.
Andreas:It shows you that the identity of my ego is something very dubious.
Andreas:So it's not something set in stone, it's something which I realize through
Andreas:togetherness with other beings, I realize through the fact that I am actually
Andreas:not just a sim simple single self.
Andreas:You see?
Andreas:It's, yeah.
Andreas:Okay.
Andreas:I stop here.
Andreas:I stop here.
Andreas:You have more question?
Andreas:Yeah.
Andreas:. Kate: I, I'm a farmer and I, I raise
Andreas:about intimacy within our food system and intimacy within our biology, and I think
Andreas:that you explained it in a, a way that I cannot, but we have this relationship
Andreas:that happens when we, when we eat, where this matter that in, I think in
Andreas:many ways is borrowed from deep time.
Andreas:This is how I think of this, right?
Andreas:We are just, we are just borrowing this matter, but this matter that was
Andreas:once other in the form of, of plants or animals, whatever that is, becomes a part
Andreas:of us as it diffuses through this one cell wall thick membrane in our intestines.
Andreas:And I think this blurs that boundary, which is diaphanous to
Andreas:begin with, of self and other.
Andreas:And then to bring in this other piece here we are home to many microorganisms.
Andreas:We're home to bacteria and fungi and yeast.
Andreas:Yeah.
Andreas:Uh, whose genetic material very well might out number our own.
Andreas:Yeah, it does.
Andreas:And so, yeah.
Andreas:And so that relationship of what is self and what is identity and that, that
Andreas:boundary that isn't fixed of my organism as all of these different, all of this
Andreas:matter recursively cycles through.
Andreas:And I think to bring it back too, to, to bring in this other piece that we
Andreas:have this sort of reductive view in science, while all of these things
Andreas:are empirically true, that is so serving to the self of the individual
Andreas:and the parts rather than the whole.
Andreas:And so there's this tension between self and other, between parts and whole.
Andreas:Yeah.
Andreas:Yeah.
Andreas:You, well, I mean, you you nailed it.
Andreas:So, so it's actually the, the, the way we see the world is not, it's not
Andreas:following the way the world is, but the, the way we should see the world
Andreas:because the prevailing discourse.
Andreas:Wants it to be, or you could even say the prevailing power structures prefer
Andreas:this because they prefer the competitive view, um, in which violence is legitimate.
Andreas:And, but, but we can, I mean, it's easy to, to to truly look, to really
Andreas:look at at what there is and then it, this will change our view.
Andreas:And as you say, we, we can even go a step, step back.
Andreas:Before that, what I started to explain by, by our metabolism.
Andreas:And we can look at what one biological unit is one organism.
Andreas:And we see there's not no such thing as one organism.
Andreas:And one organism is always many organisms.
Andreas:And, and in this scale of being linked to the ecosystem, but also in on the level of
Andreas:what is actually my, um, organic identity or the organic identity of a cell.
Andreas:And if you go back in biological time, as you know, then we know that the
Andreas:cells, the type of cell we are made from and plans and animals are made
Andreas:from, are actually made from combined a combination of different cells.
Andreas:So that's, that's, um, endosymbiosis, which Lynn Marus discovered, and she
Andreas:had difficulties to get this through because all these , these male competitive
Andreas:colleagues didn't want her to, to, to be, to have this, to find this.
Andreas:But she prevails because it's, you can prove it.
Andreas:You see, even when I, when I bought this book, I was in school, we
Andreas:were taught her theory along other theories, and it wasn't decided.
Andreas:So we, we learned several theories of how the higher self came to be, but
Andreas:now it is clear this has been settled.
Andreas:And so, so actually there is no such thing as one single individual, which
Andreas:you can in any way detach from the rest.
Andreas:This is a myth and it's, it's actually, well, it's a myth, but it's also wrong.
Andreas:And if you use a wrongness in order to find your way, then you'll
Andreas:hurt yourself and you hurt others.
Andreas:And that's, that's what, what is happening right now.
Andreas:So, so you, you, you, you have a, you'll leave a trail of destruction
Andreas:if you have, if your maps are wrong and your ideas are wrong, then in
Andreas:inevitably you'll destroy beings, things, others, and you destroy yourself.
Andreas:I mean, it's like, like literally if you have a wrong map and the tank and you
Andreas:follow the, that which is not a street and you plow through houses and forests,
Andreas:et cetera, and you destroy a lot of things because you have a wrong idea
Andreas:of what there is and what there is not.
Andreas:That's, that's a way, a little bit like what, what, um, happens
Andreas:be because of this idea of, um, competition between individuals,
Andreas:which, which are somehow always about defending themselves against others.
Andreas:Yeah.
Andreas:I mean the, the whole thing that self is only.
Andreas:Is only possible as other i'd, I'd really put it like this.
Andreas:So self is other.
Andreas:Yeah.
Andreas:You know, you can't, you cannot even, you cannot even, doesn't make
Andreas:sense at all to, to detach those.
Andreas:And, and then again, other, you know, coming back to this thing, which is the
Andreas:sentence which is still in the chat, this other is also self, you know, so
Andreas:it's not that horrible because this other is also self and, um, yeah, it's, I, I
Andreas:envy you for your beautiful profession and for, for your beautiful occupation,
Andreas:which is, um, about nourishing life, which is actually what is life is about.
Andreas:Life is about nourishing life and it's also painful profession
Andreas:in this world, I imagine.
Andreas:Very painful.
Andreas:Yes.
Andreas:Um, yeah.
Andreas:So, so it's, you see, it is all there.
Andreas:And again, no, no biologist or very few biologists would, would contradict me.
Andreas:When I say, um, on, on, on the level of looking at the organism,
Andreas:there, there is no nothing which is sort of rock solid self.
Andreas:It's, it's always the process of, well, my, my teacher said
Andreas:reciprocal specification.
Andreas:It's, it is always se self is other, or he said Varela Francisco, Varela.
Andreas:He used this term that organisms are meshwork of selfless self, you
Andreas:know, And, um, so, so all these ideas of defending and, and fighting
Andreas:and struggling, it's, it's at, at best it's a fragment of reality.
Andreas:And, and, and in many cases it's just, it's just a myth
Andreas:or a lie, , you could say.
Andreas:And, um, there was just one thing I wanted to add, which is ah, yeah, because,
Andreas:because, um, defending the self is a metaphor of immunology and of illness.
Andreas:It's, it's about, um, invaders, alien invaders attacking an intact body.
Andreas:And if you go to the, if you're looking at how the immune system works, then you
Andreas:understand that it's not at all like this.
Andreas:It doesn't work like this.
Andreas:So there is nothing which is already an intact body.
Andreas:So the immune system on a profound level is actually about, um, establishing a
Andreas:sense of identity from moment to moment.
Andreas:It's, it's not about defending anything, which is already there.
Andreas:It's about realizing something very fleeting.
Andreas:And, um, so, so this whole meta ology, this whole i imagery is from war
Andreas:imagery, you know, there's, the enemy is, is on the other side of the border.
Andreas:Yeah.
Andreas:Which unfortunately, Happens, I mean, as we can see in Europe.
Andreas:So these things happen, but it's, this is not, this is not how body
Andreas:bodies work, so this is not how life works and how life should work.
Andreas:Okay.
Andreas:Yeah.
Kate:Well, I wonder as, as you were speaking, if, if we've come to view
Kate:life in the metaphors of competition, then it, and I think through your
Kate:work, what you're establishing is the idea of collaboration and of inter
Kate:beingness to go back to you Francisco Varela, to to call it reciprocity,
Kate:to call it an, a reciprocal act.
Kate:Mm-hmm.
Kate:And, and to recognize, I guess, in it, I, and I'm not quite sure what
Kate:my question is yet, but that we are constantly exerting change on one another.
Kate:Mm-hmm.
Kate:Um, through our environment and through this act of reciprocity
Kate:and co-creation that you can't really tease one from the other.
Kate:Like we are, we are creating our environment and that is
Andreas:creating us.
Andreas:Yeah.
Andreas:That's important.
Andreas:I mean, even the word environment is somehow misleading, because
Andreas:then we immediately have the idea, okay, there's a, there's a back.
Andreas:That's the background and I'm the foreground.
Andreas:Mm-hmm.
Andreas:somehow, somehow we are that which we call environment.
Andreas:Also like, like when I tell you that, that when I breathe out, that's, that's
Andreas:the carbon, the carbon in the air.
Andreas:Is my body, which is then feeding the tree.
Andreas:So actually in the moment I breathe it out, it's my
Andreas:environment, but it's still me.
Andreas:You know, it is also me and then it, it becomes the tree and the, but
Andreas:I'll, I'll eat the fruit of the tree.
Andreas:So it's still me in a way.
Andreas:So it doesn't make sense at all.
Andreas:Doesn't make sense at all.
Andreas:But I mean, this follows an old tendency of western thinking to, to separate
Andreas:into the only the sole agents and the rest of the world, which is just things.
Andreas:So we need to see that this ideology of competition, um, builds on, on
Andreas:something, um, older, which made it only possible, which is the idea of the
Andreas:hierarchy of, um, being and, um, humans.
Andreas:And we need to see, so in, in brackets, um, particularly white male,
Andreas:western humans, um, are, um, very much on top, just, just below God.
Andreas:And they can decide who is a thing and who is, um, equal.
Andreas:And, and then all these links and all these mutual transformations are
Andreas:declared non-existent and must be suppressed and must be destroyed.
Andreas:And that's what we are seeing.
Andreas:But it's, it's, it's, it's, it is really wrong.
Andreas:And, and I mean, it, we, we, we do see competition.
Andreas:So we do see, we do see in, in this reciprocal transformation,
Andreas:we do see any e every form of, um, complication and struggle.
Andreas:So it's not a, I'm not talking about a sort of harmonious paradise where,
Andreas:where, where there's only happiness, but, but all these complications happen
Andreas:on the ground of a profound identity or a profound interchangeability and seen
Andreas:through this, they become something very different as this ble competition
Andreas:around, um, getting hold of the biggest number of objects which are lying around.
Andreas:It's, it's, I I really see this as a, as a failed metaphysics.
Andreas:It's, it's, and it's a, it's a sort of, how would you say it, this in
Andreas:English, it's, it's a sort of strange exception from other metaphysics.
Andreas:So if you look at cultures, the, the, you rarely see like other
Andreas:cultures, older cultures, indigenous cultures, eastern cultures.
Andreas:You don't see a thing like western culture where there is, where there
Andreas:is this clean separation between the only, the only real agent and all the
Andreas:rest, which, which can be dominated.
Andreas:It's, it's, it's a strange aberration.
Andreas:Well, that's the word I was looking for.
Andreas:It's very straight that this happened actually.
Andreas:Because, because it's, it doesn't, it doesn't make.
Andreas:The participants feel well, , it makes everybody, and it, it started,
Andreas:it, it, and it didn't make the participants feel well for centuries.
Andreas:So it's, it's because, because of, because competitions becomes the, the,
Andreas:actually the main occupation of everyone.
Andreas:And because this strange split goes through everyone.
Andreas:So I am, as we know, that's called the, the problem of dualism or
Andreas:the mind body problem or whatever, however we call it the strange split.
Andreas:That on one hand I am this, this commander of the only agent.
Andreas:And on the other hand, I'm obviously part of outer space as well,
Andreas:because I'm made of matter and, and, and how can I reconcile this?
Andreas:And so that's, that's the profound problem of Western thinking.
Andreas:And if you go back to looking at philosophy of the, the lineage of
Andreas:philosophy in the west, starting with Plato, you see that they try
Andreas:to understand this enigma, which actually was a creation of a worldview.
Andreas:So if you start to view the world as profoundly split, and it isn't so
Andreas:beyond your view, it behaves as non, not split, but you insist on having this
Andreas:wrong view, then st things become very enigmatic and you cannot explain them.
Andreas:And, you know, and, and, and you feel lost.
Andreas:You feel lost in this world because, You are the only one.
Andreas:Okay.
Andreas:Everything else is dead stuff.
Andreas:Oh God.
Andreas:So what can I do?
Andreas:How can I connect?
Andreas:And, and it's, it's, it's actually horrible.
Andreas:It's, it's a sort of, it, it's, it's acute trauma pathology and, and, um,
Andreas:which builds the, the ba the bad rock of Western culture in many respects.
Andreas:So that's where we are.
Kate:I think too, I wanna bring into this the word isolation that I think
Kate:in that split we become isolated and to, for beings that exist in
Kate:relationship to everything else, I think isolation is, is incredibly traumatic.
Kate:I, in that, I'm curious what you think it would take to heal that rift.
Kate:And I actually wanna pull something that you said about healing at
Kate:the end of was either matter and desire or the biology of wonder.
Kate:Um, you said nature does not confer salvation, but healing.
Kate:Healing means to transform the oscillating dance on the razor's edge
Kate:of a aliveness into the beauty of a new imagination of what life can mean.
Kate:It is a process, not a state, and fuzz never to be secured.
Kate:It is a dynamic balance tied to the moment and to the situation.
Kate:Healing means to overcome the cleft between the individual and the
Kate:other, between the individual and the whole for one short moment.
Kate:You go on to say, healing does not signify finding the definite
Kate:answer, but responding with another more interesting question.
Andreas:Hmm.
Andreas:Yeah.
Andreas:It's very interesting to, I think that's, that's biology of wonder.
Andreas:I, it's very interesting to, to reread myself or to, to listen to myself
Andreas:at a, at a, um, well, it's still the same project, it's still my work and,
Andreas:but I'm on an on somewhere, on a, on another level, let's say I'm looking
Andreas:at it from a, from another perspective.
Andreas:It's very interesting to see that, um, to, to see the same idea,
Andreas:um, confirmed in a way in, in my more, more recent experiences.
Andreas:And you see what I, what I say there, I still again come back to real care.
Andreas:So that will be our guiding light, obviously, and in many,
Andreas:I like that as a touchstone.
Andreas:Yeah.
Andreas:Yeah.
Andreas:Well, it's a lovely touchstone is real Care as a touchstone.
Andreas:So I, I've come back, Jim, in, in two respects.
Andreas:So first, and I probably, I knew this somehow, so I was a
Andreas:little bit alluding to this.
Andreas:So, so he, one of his most famous sayings is he wrote in, in his letters
Andreas:to a young poet that in order, instead of searching the answers, it would
Andreas:be better to live the question.
Andreas:And, um, so I'm somehow alluding to this and what that means, I'd say, Is to
Andreas:surrender, to surrender to into being.
Andreas:And in, into allowing to let down, to break, let break down your, the,
Andreas:the, the borders of your momentarily self, which you are right now.
Andreas:And, and just letting, allowing yourself to, to transform yourself into, into
Andreas:what you are not yet into what is other and in, into what you will be.
Andreas:This is the way of the biosphere and this is the way of our body.
Andreas:And this is somehow also, I mean, not only somehow, it's surely also the way
Andreas:of our, um, living experience only that we are so afraid of this all the time.
Andreas:And, but if we live in a cosmos, which in no point ever is alien to us because
Andreas:actually it is made from that which is in our inner innermost center,
Andreas:then we can trustfully surrender.
Andreas:At least we could try to convince ourselves, , that we could trustfully
Andreas:and, and when, where this conviction, this, this work of convincing ourselves
Andreas:and of gaining trust it happens is among other beings other than human
Andreas:beings who, who actually, um, very trustfully do this all the time.
Andreas:And I think that's, that's one of the profound healing powers of,
Andreas:um, what has been called nature.
Andreas:What I don't like to call nature because it sounds so much like a big, nice object.
Andreas:And, um, and as, as I was talking about healing there, healing against salvation,
Andreas:healing is letting yourself into this process of flourishing, blossoming
Andreas:through, giving away, through, letting go through mutual transformation.
Andreas:And I think when we walk into nature, into landscape, into, into the society
Andreas:of being, I'm looking out of my window where, where these, these early blossoms
Andreas:start to break from the buds of the trees.
Andreas:It seems like right now, because it's a sunny afternoon and, uh,
Andreas:it's a bit warmer, it was very cold.
Andreas:So somehow they, they all feel like, okay, wow, let's go.
Andreas:Like it happens before my eyes while, while I'm talking to you.
Andreas:So, so this is, um, that's why so many people such this without knowing.
Andreas:So then, then others talk, tell them, well, you know, this is
Andreas:forest bothering because it's there, they're good molecules around.
Andreas:Which, which is true.
Andreas:But what is actually happening is that there is, is a profound connection
Andreas:into, into the metamorphosis of being, which is profoundly healing,
Andreas:but it is not rescuing yourself.
Andreas:It's more, much more stressing your impermanence.
Andreas:And, um, and it's nice.
Andreas:I mean, we can bear it if, if we can bear it, if we go there, it's,
Andreas:it works because actually we.
Andreas:We get, we get teaching from all these other beings who are mentors,
Andreas:and that helps tremendously.
Andreas:Yeah.
Andreas:I'm, I'm, I'm, I don't completely entirely remember the question,
Andreas:actually, but maybe, maybe I didn't answer it or said something
Kate:else.
Kate:No, no.
Kate:I think that oftentimes a question leads to one place.
Kate:Oh, true.
Kate:That is, yes.
Kate:Is exactly where it's supposed to be.
Kate:True.
Kate:That's true.
Andreas:If that makes sense.
Andreas:The question which I tried to Yeah.
Andreas:Yeah.
Andreas:I, I, I, I had to live into it and in order to get out
Andreas:with another question mm-hmm.
Andreas:with another, okay.
Andreas:Okay.
Andreas:Yeah.
Kate:So, and I think you've, you've put us in this place, you know, you mentioned
Kate:surrender, and I think that this is such a beautiful place to begin, and the
Kate:surrender to the idea of impermanence.
Kate:And I think a lot about, uh, there's something about being on the farm that I
Kate:think calls death back to place, right?
Kate:Mm-hmm.
Kate:, that this is something that feels like a part of, maybe not my daily
Kate:experience, but this frequent experience.
Kate:And, uh, my, my friend James related recently, the idea that in many
Kate:ways, agriculture took what was a circle and broke it into a line.
Kate:And I've been thinking a lot about what it would mean to resolder.
Kate:The line into a circle again.
Kate:And I think that there is this point that is death, that we have really
Kate:pushed to the side as part of the transformative experience that is
Kate:life and aliveness, and to come home to death and impermanence in a way to
Kate:maybe, maybe begin to heal that rift.
Kate:To go back to that, that first question, but certainly to
Kate:feel our own aliveness and to
Kate:begin that process of surrender.
Kate:Mm-hmm.
Kate:. Andreas: Yeah, I agree.
Kate:Completely agree.
Kate:So talking about or, or letting, allowing death to enter the picture.
Kate:Um, I think two things are, are important.
Kate:Um, I see two things as important at, at this point.
Kate:And, and one thing is that death is real and death is a transition,
Kate:which is a profound challenge.
Kate:And I'm, I'm not talking only, I'm not only talking about death as end as the
Kate:end of our individual embodied existences.
Kate:I'm also talking about this, but also death as little ends in little.
Kate:Smaller things and life, parts of life and projects and, and, and so, so there's,
Kate:yes, death, death is everywhere and it's, it is needed, but it is a challenge.
Kate:So it's important to see that it's a challenge.
Kate:So it's important to see, or for me, it's important to
Kate:stress that, how can I put it?
Kate:That we need to see with, with this double vision, we need to see that something
Kate:can be a profound challenge, but it can also be, um, an incredible rewarding
Kate:transformation in, in both together.
Kate:So I don't want to make any, um, publici publicizing for, um, for
Kate:a, a beautiful world in which death is an illusion in, in a way it is.
Kate:But as we are embodied, it is a challenge.
Kate:So, so it's important, and it's important to see this because in being a challenge,
Kate:and now I'm trying to hone in on, on the term surrender, which is very important
Kate:to me, even right now in my work right now, it's a very important term, very
Kate:important practice be because it, it gives you the opportunity to surrender
Kate:and it's, this is very important.
Kate:So you see, death is, in a way, what, what death does is break down your ego.
Kate:And, um, it, it will break down your ego in bi big time . That's,
Kate:that's when you, when, when, when the obi obituary is written.
Kate:But it also breaks down your ego in small times when you, when things
Kate:don't work or break up or, or, or crash or you give up, you have to give
Kate:up something or you have to digest failure or go to go through grief.
Kate:So this is a, an occasion to, to, to find yourself as something
Kate:bigger, into something bigger.
Kate:And, um, I don't say this as a cheap recipe, but it's not something which you
Kate:can put down bookmark and then pull out when it is, when the time is there and
Kate:said, okay, this guy said, well, actually that's, that's my occasion to surrender,
Kate:so I'll do this and everything is fine.
Kate:So it's, it's really like falling into the void.
Kate:But in surrendering to this fall, one realizes that you are meeting yourself
Kate:and you're meeting in yourself.
Kate:You're meeting this luminous ground, which is the stuff this reality is
Kate:made from and from which life comes.
Kate:That's the ground where life grows and it can only grow if we do surrender.
Kate:And, um, it, it might sound a bit mystical because it is . It's, it's, so,
Kate:it's not nothing which you can do, it's nothing which you can do, um, on purpose.
Kate:Like, okay, I do this and I do that and then I'll get out this.
Kate:So it's something which, cuz you never know because it's a true challenge
Kate:because it's truly, it means truly to say goodbye to your status, your your being
Kate:in this moment and you have no idea and you need to close your eyes and fall or
Kate:jump and then you will be transformed.
Kate:And that's how, that's, that's actually what makes it possible
Kate:to be individual and to be part of this total coherent togetherness.
Kate:This is, it's, it's only works like this and it always brings you back into this
Kate:bigger togetherness and it always brings forth birth from this bigger togetherness.
Kate:But it's, it's always a struggle.
Kate:And this is why all cultures have their, um, ways to celebrate that.
Kate:And, and so there's no culture in which death is somehow just noded away.
Kate:So, okay, no problem.
Kate:Death.
Kate:It's, it's always related to, to, to deep celebration and to mourning and to grief
Kate:slash praise as, um, Martine prick tell.
Kate:So, Extremely poignantly, beautifully says so it's surrendering to the grief.
Kate:Coming with death is at the same time the praise of the life, which in heres
Kate:in death or in that which had to die.
Kate:Which needed to die.
Kate:Yeah.
Kate:So that's, that's what I can say to that at the moment.
Kate:And it goes without saying that in, in our culture, all these
Kate:things are not trained at all.
Kate:So this is, this is all something which, um, doesn't happen because it,
Kate:in, in our culture, death is to be avoided and it's shunned and put to
Kate:the side, which leads to the fact that there's so much death in our culture.
Kate:And I mean, as, as you're a farmer, you, you, you're as a farmer, as a conventional
Kate:farmer, you're, you're the messenger of death because you're killing you.
Kate:It's killing so much lives all the time.
Kate:That's the way you're, you do agro, technocratic farming,
Kate:that's like distributing death.
Kate:Um, in order to, to push death away, you, you're buying into death, which
Kate:is a horrible paradox of our culture.
Kate:Yeah.
Kate:You look like you want to.
Kate:Ask one more question into what I have been saying, and while you're
Kate:thinking about this, I'm going to, I'm going, I'm going to do two things.
Kate:I'm going to the bathroom and I'm going to get me two cookies.
Kate:brought a bag of Italian cookies and I, I actually questions make
Kate:me hungry, so I I'll Perfect.
Kate:That's
Kate:okay.
Kate:Yeah.
Kate:Yeah.
Kate:I'll consider
Andreas:my question.
Andreas:Yeah.
Andreas:If it's, if it wouldn't be okay, I still had to do it.
Andreas:Okay.
Andreas:Do you have your cookies?
Andreas:I have.
Andreas:I hope it won't be too in intrusive when I, when I munch one.
Andreas:Let's
Kate:see.
Kate:You know, I, I really appreciate the sort of idiosyncrasies that come
Kate:through on these recordings of dogs and trains and various other phenomena
Kate:that make their way into Yeah.
Kate:Love into this.
Kate:That gives it some life, I think.
Kate:Very good.
Kate:Yes.
Kate:Doesn't need to be sterile, so eat the cookie.
Kate:Um,
Kate:I've had this, this thought recently and this called to it, you know, I
Kate:heard you say in an interview that you have this vow to embrace the necessary
Kate:deaths that we go through mm-hmm.
Kate:throughout life.
Kate:And I think that, Some of these could be defined as rights of
Kate:passage that, that I think we've largely lost in western culture.
Kate:And I think others can be described as been thinking some
Kate:of about the life cycle of a star.
Kate:Right?
Kate:And as it begins to die, it creates this void.
Kate:And as you said, you know, we have to go into that abyss that, that we have
Kate:to go into that pain or that grief.
Kate:And I think that in seeking to, to live forever or to have life in perpetuity in
Kate:the way that much of our culture has kind of framed this, and to push away death, we
Kate:have also pushed away the transformative nature of grief and of pain.
Kate:And one of the things you said towards the end of matter and desire was there is no
Kate:transformation that does not also hurt.
Kate:Mm-hmm.
Kate:, the pain is part of reality.
Kate:Every experience is one of being wounded by reality, but also unavoidably
Kate:one of being transformed by reality.
Kate:Hmm.
Kate:And I think within that, I, and I don't know quite where the question is, but we
Kate:have, we have siloed death away from us.
Kate:We've, we've outsourced it in our technocratic agricultural situation.
Kate:And in that I think we have also.
Kate:Foregone a lot of the, the grief and pain with which comes transformation.
Andreas:Mm-hmm.
Andreas:. Yeah.
Andreas:I mean the, the problem is to forsaken transformation because when, when,
Andreas:when we say like we, we did at the beginning, that self is all the time.
Andreas:Other then for forsaking transformation means to kill yourself, to stop, to
Andreas:stop your own individual existence.
Andreas:So it's very shortsighted to, to, to plan like this.
Andreas:And we can see right now as we are at the, we're standing at the fringe, um,
Andreas:of this earth historical abyss, which is called climate heating or sixth
Andreas:extinction or whatever you call it, which is inevitable, which will happen.
Andreas:We see that this is, this is, and, and we, we know that this is due to
Andreas:fossil fuels on which capitalism runs.
Andreas:So, so we, we really know that this is in intimately linked to
Andreas:the project of, um, shunning death.
Andreas:And, and, and, and you see what this brings.
Andreas:So it it, you, if, if you are a, you are part of, of a, of a living hole,
Andreas:which constantly recreates itself.
Andreas:As its center then to, to, to try to avoid death, which is a part of this recreation.
Andreas:You know, every recreation, every creation, every creation and, and
Andreas:new creation means that you need to give up something in order to have
Andreas:the ground for, for a new creation.
Andreas:So if you say, okay, we, we want all the good, all the goodies, all the
Andreas:nice things, but we don't want this, this disturbing death, then you,
Andreas:again, you ignore part of what is real.
Andreas:You ignore actually the center of what is real because we, we have
Andreas:seen that that death links us to the whole, and it does so much more than
Andreas:ecstasy, which also can link us to the whole, but it is, the door is death.
Andreas:And, and if we say, okay, this, this doesn't exist, but we have philosophers
Andreas:who, who tell us, well, it, it, it exists, but it's nasty and we can somehow put
Andreas:it, let, let's just try to not think about it too much and to avoid it.
Andreas:And, uh, invent technologies, which for the elites at least
Andreas:make it, um, far and far away.
Andreas:Then you ignore what there is and, and you, you don't even ignore it.
Andreas:You destroy what the, the, the working of the, the world.
Andreas:And that's, that's what we've been doing.
Andreas:And it's, I mean, it's, it's incredibly naive actually.
Andreas:You know, the, the western culture has deemed itself always so superior
Andreas:to all other cultures, irrational and so, so empirical and so, um,
Andreas:unsentimental and whate whatnot, and so out blooded and well calculating and,
Andreas:and then it is so incredibly naive.
Andreas:It's like children who, who hide under the table and don't want
Andreas:to, don't want to see reality.
Andreas:It's incredibly naive and, and it doesn't work as we see now.
Andreas:I mean, if you want a definition of the anthrop scene, it's that realizing that
Andreas:the idea to shun death does not work.
Andreas:That's actually what is happening in the anthrop scene.
Andreas:And as we, we would never realize it, like, like not the majority or not
Andreas:the power of people in power realizing it in a, in a, in a mature way of
Andreas:saying, okay, that that was wrong.
Andreas:So let's try to get it right.
Andreas:We realize it by being killed by it and, and, and with, with,
Andreas:with us a lot of others who, who actually don't really deserve it.
Andreas:So it's a, it's a, it's a form of realizing, which you cannot really
Andreas:avoid , but it's on the other hand, you see on the other hand, it's
Andreas:just, again, it, it is a, it is it.
Andreas:This whole, you can see this whole pro process as a huge.
Andreas:Horrible breakdown, but you can also see it as a rebirth.
Andreas:It's a, it's a preparation for rebirth.
Andreas:So, so difficult to get there, but on, on, on some place.
Andreas:Everything is totally okay.
Andreas:And, and there's some level of, of, of the life, the living soul of the cosmos
Andreas:or the principle of life as such, there's some level which we cannot touch at all.
Andreas:We have absolutely no access, so we can be as powerful as we want.
Andreas:We have no access at all.
Andreas:And this is just, this is just doing what needs to be done in order to give life.
Andreas:And what needs to be done right now is to, to override this wrong
Andreas:way of, of misunderstanding of what, what this world is about.
Andreas:And it's easy, it's easy to, very easy to override it.
Andreas:And, and, and we, we, we are so powerless.
Andreas:We don't, many people don't know how powerless we are.
Andreas:We can see now a little bit and well, it's still, it's still sad to see
Andreas:so many beautiful beings somehow not being able to continue their lifelines.
Andreas:That's the faint coughing, which you hear in the background is my dog, by the way.
Andreas:Just talking about dogs.
Andreas:, she's, she's now elderly.
Andreas:She's be 16, so she, she has some, some dry cough from time to day.
Andreas:Hmm.
Andreas:Maybe she wants a piece of cookie, but
Kate:I think that would probably help cookies help everything.
Kate:Yeah.
Kate:Cool.
Kate:I, I think I have a question in here, there, sometimes I wonder if we have to
Kate:go through this process of grand loss to give way to whatever comes next.
Kate:And I, I wanna pull in as we talk about the six mass extinction event,
Kate:something that you said and, and you said, we are part of a web of meaningful
Kate:inter penetrations of being that are corporeal and psychologically real.
Kate:At the same time, human can only fully comprehend their own inwardness if
Kate:they understand their existence as cultural beings who are existentially
Kate:tied to the symbolic processes, active inside nature for humans.
Kate:The biggest risk of biodiversity loss is that it would bury this understanding.
Kate:Hmm.
Kate:And this idea that in this, in this massive, and I think what is unfathomable
Kate:loss that we are living through is,
Kate:and, and I, I wonder if this resonates, is both the loss of this chance to
Kate:know ourselves in the interconnected web of life and perhaps a process by
Kate:which we might come back to knowing.
Kate:The interconnected web of life
Andreas:itself.
Andreas:Mm-hmm.
Andreas:Yeah.
Andreas:How, how would I, how would I say the same thing today?
Andreas:So, so I think what what is actually really worth of knowing and what
Andreas:we actually can easily know and only for some reason, have so much
Andreas:difficulties to know is how it is to be alive, how it is to be truly alive.
Andreas:And we, we know this because this is, this is our core.
Andreas:So, so in this moment, you know how it is to be alive, but it might
Andreas:be very difficult to access it in a, in a clear way because our
Andreas:culture has done so many things to, to somehow block access to this.
Andreas:But when, when you were very young, you, you, you consisted only of this, you know,
Andreas:that that was when you, when you, even in the womb, I mean, even before , even
Andreas:when you were not one but two cells, that was, that was your knowing because that's
Andreas:in the center of every living being.
Andreas:And, and that's what other living beings can teach us all the time.
Andreas:That's what they.
Andreas:Tell us that's, that's, that's what we learned from them.
Andreas:That's, that's the message.
Andreas:And that's actually, that's actually all there is to, to share the, the
Andreas:knowledge and the practice of being alive in, in a living reality.
Andreas:So that's, it's actually what, what what we're, what we are doing is, and
Andreas:you see the, the, the strange way of self-fulfilling prophecy is to, to let go
Andreas:of this knowledge, to not longer access this knowledge to, to not longer want this
Andreas:knowledge in, in telling ourselves, not, not you and me, not me telling you or you
Andreas:telling me, but, but like in the, in the mainstream of this world actually is dead
Andreas:and it's only made of things, et cetera.
Andreas:So we, and, and then it becomes dead and it, it, it goes down and it needs
Andreas:to pass through this invisible part of the circle in order to come back.
Andreas:But the, the, the center of all knowledge and all knowledge about existence is to,
Andreas:is the experience of being part of life.
Andreas:And that this is, this is the only thing that counts.
Andreas:I'd say this is the only interesting thing.
Andreas:There's a, there's a nice, um, very famous phrase from the philosophers
Andreas:Beza, who was a great mystic as well, and the Pam psyche, as you'd say today.
Andreas:And he said the.
Andreas:What, what did he say?
Andreas:I, I might slightly misquote him, but I, I still, I still quote him.
Andreas:He says, the, the, the person who lives in truth is not at,
Andreas:at least interested in death.
Andreas:He's only interested in life.
Andreas:Mm-hmm.
Andreas:And, and what I say here is a little bit the same as I said before.
Andreas:So you see, life is actually, is, is is the core and the extension.
Andreas:It's actually, that's actually what is, what is happening here.
Andreas:And, and, and death is only, it's a passage in the self realization of
Andreas:life, but it's not, it's not, it's not really, it's not really of importance.
Andreas:And what is really, what is important is to follow the, the necessities of life
Andreas:and the needs of life and the, the, the desires of life and the protocols of life.
Andreas:This is important.
Andreas:And whatever you encounter is of very minor importance as
Andreas:long as you clinging to life.
Andreas:And, and our culture turned this on the head.
Andreas:So, so it's just, just completely disconnected this
Andreas:necessity to be in service.
Andreas:You can also say, be in service of life.
Andreas:So the per person who lives in truth is only interested to be in service of life
Andreas:because this means to live in truth.
Andreas:That's, that's truth.
Andreas:Be in service of life.
Andreas:And as you, you, you, you quoted this passage and other than human beings
Andreas:have much less difficulty to do this.
Andreas:They're, they're much wiser.
Andreas:That's why, why many indigenous peoples always defer to the knowledge of, other
Andreas:than human beings, persons, because they know that they're much wiser.
Andreas:They really know what to do.
Andreas:They, they do it under all circumstances and they not try to, to, to run away.
Andreas:And they, they accept that they might be killed if they keep on
Andreas:going, but they nevertheless do it.
Andreas:And, and, and many, in many ancient cultures, humans are, are the, the
Andreas:youngest disciples of other living elders other than human living elders
Andreas:because they know it is about life.
Andreas:And, um, I think that's what I wanted to say, or that's what I, what I said
Andreas:in, in, in a slightly different way.
Andreas:So staying with these other than human mentors means that we are constantly
Andreas:taught that it is about life.
Andreas:So, so we don't lose it.
Andreas:So we stay connected to it.
Andreas:And, and I mean, and, and that's against something very simple.
Andreas:So if, if you or anybody feels profoundly connected to their own aliveness, they
Andreas:feel profoundly real and profoundly happy.
Andreas:Nobody would ever give away this.
Andreas:Ecstatic feeling of being in this center in the middle of your lifeness.
Andreas:So that's actually what we, what we are searching.
Andreas:So it is actually very easy.
Andreas:This, this is, this is the only thing that counts.
Andreas:All the rest, all the material, culture, everything else, success status.
Andreas:That's very secondary.
Andreas:But we, we've forgotten this , many have forgotten, but it's, it's not far away.
Andreas:It's not really far away, but it, it needs some, some resolve to, to,
Andreas:to go and sit with this own luminous center of a liveness, which is there,
Andreas:which is, which is in your heart.
Andreas:The, the Sufis call it the heart of hearts.
Andreas:It's there, it's there with everyone.
Andreas:And then again, it's, it's, it, it waits for you in the,
Andreas:in, in outer space as well.
Andreas:So it's the same stuff.
Andreas:It's the same thing.
Andreas:And, and that's, that's what counts.
Andreas:And, um, I, I, I don't mean that, that everybody should all at all
Andreas:times be concentrated only on this, that that would be asking a lot too
Andreas:much because it's be, being, being on that level of awareness all the time
Andreas:is, is not really compatible with.
Andreas:Everyday tasks of keeping yourself alive.
Andreas:I don't say this, but I say that the culture should know that it, that it, it
Andreas:is, it, it should be centered around this.
Andreas:So it should be actually a culture of service, of service to life and
Andreas:the distribution of tasks that should follow this idea of service to life.
Andreas:And again, looking back at older cultures and traditional cultures and
Andreas:indigenous cultures, they are alway always cultures of service, of life.
Andreas:And, and if you go back as a farmer to earlier forms of living with the land
Andreas:or living as country, with country, as they say in Australia, they use
Andreas:country then, then, I mean, as you know, there, there, there were always
Andreas:some forms of agriculture in a way of, of co-creation, of abundance.
Andreas:Um, but they were forms of co-creation of abundance in service of life.
Andreas:And, and they were in, in case of doubt.
Andreas:The, the, the attitude of the humans was you first, the others first.
Andreas:We, we are second.
Andreas:We are the younger brothers.
Andreas:We need to be taught.
Andreas:We need to, we need to refrain.
Andreas:So, so what, what goes first is, is life and not me.
Andreas:You see this is, that's, that's nothing else than what Spinoza says
Andreas:in, in this famous phrase, actually.
Andreas:It's nothing else.
Andreas:It's just saying life first in me second and life first.
Andreas:And this life includes my own spark in my own center, in my part of art.
Andreas:You see what a little cookie can do.
Andreas:. Kate: Well, cookie cup.
Andreas:Long way.
Andreas:I was thinking as you were speaking about one of my favorite
Andreas:activities is to watch, uh, one of our goats outside chewing its cud.
Andreas:Mm-hmm.
Andreas:. And I think that there's an interesting tension for me.
Andreas:I often think that aliveness and, and, and joy and that service to
Andreas:life is the paray to the apogee of, of grief and, and mm-hmm.
Andreas:We need these poles in some ways to, to create our, our orbit around
Andreas:a aliveness and, and to touch that.
Andreas:And I was thinking about how much I learn when I sit and I watch one of our goats
Andreas:in the sunshine chewing its cut and just sort of dissolving into a complete state
Andreas:of inter being with everything else.
Andreas:At least that's how I experience the idea of an animal chewing its cut,
Andreas:is that there is this dissolution of.
Andreas:Of everything into that single moment.
Andreas:Mm-hmm.
Andreas:where it is just being that is so, that is hard for us to reach and, and easy also.
Andreas:It is, it is both things.
Andreas:Yeah.
Andreas:Yeah, yeah.
Andreas:Yeah.
Andreas:It's, yeah.
Andreas:I, I completely agree.
Andreas:It is, it's so interesting that in a way it is, it is, it is absolutely easy.
Andreas:And then going there intentionally, it can be absolutely full, can be impossible.
Andreas:It can be so difficult, but then it is very easy and you can also train
Andreas:it, you know, so people can train it.
Andreas:I've just recently listened to a little talk, a, a very famous Buddhist
Andreas:teacher of a mystic lineage, which actually happens to be the teacher of
Andreas:my teacher, my own teacher, biological teacher, philosophical teacher.
Andreas:Francisco Varela was also Buddhist.
Andreas:So this teacher, this Buddhist guru Toku, taught a way of meditation,
Andreas:which he called non-meditation.
Andreas:And, um, the only thing actually was to let go of, of your, your,
Andreas:the thinking, which names things, and just be in that moment.
Andreas:Just be there, just be there, but without effort, and, and, and I, I, I
Andreas:absolutely imagine that, you know, that.
Andreas:So many other than human beings just do this all the time.
Andreas:Mm-hmm.
Andreas:, they do this all the time.
Andreas:You know, they, they're all, they're all the time there.
Andreas:So, which, which for a, for a Buddhist disciple is the highest goal, which
Andreas:they try to reach for years and years.
Andreas:of painful exercises and the, the, the, the goat is, is there effort?
Andreas:Completely effortless.
Andreas:Cause it's, he doesn't, he doesn't think about his thoughts about this food.
Andreas:He just chews, munch, like, I mean, I mean, you, you see a
Andreas:little bit like me and the cookie.
Andreas:That's my meditative device.
Andreas:. And so you see again, what, what you described this, this, the luminous
Andreas:moment is again, nothing else but just being in your own aliveness, in
Andreas:the experience of your own aliveness.
Andreas:And, um, the, it's also beautiful that, that your goat becomes your teacher
Andreas:There, you see your goat is your guru.
Andreas:And, um, it's very important to, to realize teachers . And, and so your,
Andreas:your goat is a very, very good teacher because he's completely non-violent.
Andreas:He will, he will never.
Andreas:He will never send you into any competition or whatever.
Andreas:You will always be good enough for him.
Andreas:So you see, he's a, he's a very good teacher.
Andreas:And then at, at the other, on the other hand, he is, or she maybe
Andreas:I, I, I didn't, I didn't know.
Andreas:So I don't know he or she.
Andreas:There
Kate:are many goats.
Kate:I have many teachers.
Andreas:Very good.
Andreas:Yes.
Andreas:And, and I mean, because you see, because if a lifeness happens,
Andreas:that, that is profoundly our mentor.
Andreas:So life itself is our mentor.
Andreas:And in, in, in, in spiritual lineages, only a teacher which is
Andreas:able to transfer this, a lifeness to a disciple is a good teacher.
Andreas:It's not at all about training.
Andreas:It's really, really about coming into the center of a lifeness
Andreas:and everything starts from there.
Andreas:So for me, it's perfectly okay to have a, have a flock of goats.
Andreas:A herd of goats as teacher or a mountain or, I mean, I'm, I'm, I go to this oak
Andreas:tree in the forest close to my place and, um, meet my teacher because the, I mean,
Andreas:the only thing the teacher can convey to you is to, to, it's interesting isn't
Andreas:it, is to, to, to let you participate.
Andreas:In the gift of life.
Andreas:That's, that's the only true teaching.
Andreas:And you know what, what happens then, and this again, is, is, is cyclical.
Andreas:So if you really, if you really be, if you're given the gift of
Andreas:participating in life, you'll immediately be able to transmit this gift.
Andreas:You even, you'll even want nothing more than to transmit this gift.
Andreas:You see, if you, if you, if you receive the luminosity of life, then
Andreas:you want to give life to others.
Andreas:And you probably know this because it's part of your profession.
Andreas:And, um, but I mean, I think many people know this, and, um, artists know this
Andreas:because they, they need to produce art when they have been touched by life.
Andreas:And art is something which instills life in others.
Andreas:So you see, that's, it's also simple and it's also profound.
Andreas:Cosmic secret.
Andreas:Obvious secret that this is the way, um, a lifeness transmits
Andreas:itself by giving itself away.
Andreas:And, and we, and we can, we can know the feeling.
Andreas:I mean, isn't that fantastic?
Andreas:So we can be so absolutely, so, so much in, in the center of the, of
Andreas:this reality that we, we, we become an, the instrument of what this, the
Andreas:desire of this, of this reality is.
Andreas:We are actually this reality desiring to give life.
Andreas:Mm-hmm.
Andreas:And I mean, that's when I say, um, it should be a culture should be
Andreas:about being in service to life.
Andreas:That's, that's what I'm talking about then.
Andreas:Mm-hmm.
Andreas:Thank you
Kate:for that.
Kate:That was a beautiful explanation of exploring the reciprocal gift of
Kate:aliveness and what it inspires in us to, to put forth and, and cycle through.
Kate:I actually wanna touch on language briefly, and you, you brought this up
Kate:a little bit ago in the conversation, that the way that we have come to
Kate:define so much of our reality as, as dead things, it has this effect of,
Kate:of severing us from our aliveness.
Kate:And as I was reading all of your work, I was really struck by how often we
Kate:use the terminology of other beings to describe our own inner experience.
Kate:Whether we are watching a, a flower in bloom, or we are watching a
Kate:lake freeze over that, that relates back to us part of our inner world.
Kate:And.
Kate:Speaking of your oak tree, I pulled, I pulled a, a quote from you in this that
Kate:I, I wanted to sort of bring into the conversation, um, and we'll see how it
Kate:lands with the transformations of you that have happened since you wrote this.
Kate:We create linguistic expressions on the basis of embodied experiences, and we
Kate:can find the reference point for these experiences and other beings that embody
Kate:the same existential feelings, symbols, thus become the language of the psyche.
Kate:In this sense, the vegetative world in front of our eyes is nothing
Kate:other than our own inwardness.
Kate:Nature shows this inwardness as a silent mirror expressing before us.
Kate:What is unnameable?
Kate:Because it is within us.
Kate:In contemplating the life of a tree, a human can comprehend similar Flo
Kate:forces that he knows exists within himself without having to analyze them
Kate:because again, they are part of the self with which he organizes experience.
Kate:The naughty oak and the sea of grass grasps by the wind are living reservoirs
Kate:of understanding as when I sense my own powers of endurance or joy or melancholy.
Kate:Because the plant is always growing, it illustrates not only the principle
Kate:of self conservation in life, but also the intensification of self.
Kate:The plant is aliveness made, physical embodied in lush leaves and buds.
Kate:Impatient of bloom.
Andreas:Yeah.
Andreas:Yep.
Andreas:The plant is lifeness made physical.
Andreas:That's, that's, that's, you see, that's, um, that connects very well to what I'm,
Andreas:what I've been talking about before.
Andreas:See, that's, that's the interesting thing is that, and, and then I, I I go back
Andreas:a little bit to, to the, to the, the earlier parts of what you were coding.
Andreas:The interesting thing is that,
Andreas:that the, the, let's say the, the, the, the inner dimensions or the
Andreas:spiritual dimensions I've been talking about in the last part, in the recent
Andreas:minutes, they, they have their, their, their physical, their, their embodied
Andreas:references in the living world.
Andreas:So, so it's actually the, the realm of experiences.
Andreas:If you, if you open your eyes, you find it also, um, incarnated in the
Andreas:living bodies, and it actually, what is going on with them is the same thing.
Andreas:So, because it is the same thing.
Andreas:So you see you, but, but we, we have been so much trained to, to, to separate these
Andreas:things into, um, okay, this, this is only physical and that's my imagination.
Andreas:Um, but, but it, they are not separate.
Andreas:So, so you can, and, and I mean, when I actually, you did do this in an
Andreas:admirable way because you, you found so many important thoughts in my work.
Andreas:What, what I'm doing now is.
Andreas:Exploring much more the, let's say the, the invisible dimension.
Andreas:But the interesting thing is that what I've been been doing
Andreas:before is just the same thing.
Andreas:Only that I'm, I'm I, I've been exploring the, um, let's say the,
Andreas:the, the expressive and embodied dimension of, of the flesh.
Andreas:But it is just the same thing.
Andreas:This is so interesting.
Andreas:And, um, so it's truly the same thing.
Andreas:So it's not only, it's not, I might be a bit, a bit more radical
Andreas:now if I say, say it again.
Andreas:So, so it's what, what we might see as a symbol is actually not a symbol.
Andreas:It is the same thing happening.
Andreas:Only that we access it on, on different levels.
Andreas:And again, if you see this, if you meet this blossom, you meet this
Andreas:flower or the, the first, the little, um, blue, how are they called?
Andreas:Blue lilies coming out.
Andreas:Um, that's, it is a manifestation of life in, in individualized form.
Andreas:Like you are a manifestation of life and individualized form.
Andreas:So, so you're, you're, you, you're confronted with that
Andreas:in, in on the material level.
Andreas:So that material level actually, although it is, it is clearly a material
Andreas:physical level is also a dimension of.
Andreas:Inexperience of inwardness.
Andreas:So you, you cannot separate it.
Andreas:It is the same thing.
Andreas:So this what you see there, the blossom, the, the flower,
Andreas:the, the, the blossoming trees.
Andreas:This is inwardness exploding before your eyes.
Andreas:So you, you see, it's, it is inwardness in which you can walk
Andreas:like your own inwardness, people can bump into your own inwardness.
Andreas:So it's, it's, and I mean, it, it becomes, you see, I'm, I'm, I'm approaching a sort
Andreas:of rapture because, because I found this, I find this so generous of the cosmos.
Andreas:You know, you, you, you cannot avoid to, to be, um, embraced by this sweet
Andreas:substance you are made of yourself.
Andreas:It is absolutely incredible.
Andreas:And then, I mean, then finally, you, you even eat it , you eat it with,
Andreas:with, with joy and with with love.
Andreas:And, and I mean, did, did, did anybody ask themselves why actually we love eating?
Andreas:Yeah.
Andreas:Okay.
Andreas:The biology teacher told you Yes, because it is necessary.
Andreas:And if you love it, then it is easier done and you won't starve.
Andreas:That's what I heard is the typical Western explanation.
Andreas:But you, we love it because it's a profound mystical experience because it
Andreas:is a, it is a profound meeting of life.
Andreas:And I mean, it, it's, it's, we, we are actually, we, we, uh, eating means,
Andreas:and we touched upon this already.
Andreas:It means that, that we.
Andreas:We experience that we exchange our body with other bodies and in exchanging our
Andreas:bodies with other bodies, we confirm that both my body and this other body are part
Andreas:of this one unified whole, which desires life by, by granting this exchange.
Andreas:So, so what reason would be there not to be ecstatic in this
Andreas:experience, , but it's, it's, it's, it's a sacred experience.
Andreas:So why, why shouldn't we be ecstatic about it?
Andreas:Or drinking?
Andreas:If you're thirsty, it's the same thing.
Andreas:It's, I mean, it's a profound pleasure.
Andreas:So, so actually if we really look, we meet, we meet life everywhere and
Andreas:it teaches us everywhere, always.
Andreas:And it can be, it can have this, this dimension of, of rupture and profound
Andreas:understanding, but it also has this dimension of, um, of very simple care
Andreas:and knowing what to do next in order to keep this process of fertility
Andreas:and ongoing transmutation open.
Andreas:Do you see, it's also very, very simple.
Andreas:You see there's a plant which needs, which needs whatever help or space or
Andreas:water or, Food, then you know what to do.
Andreas:So it's in a way, it's, it's, it's also, it's not only, it doesn't only
Andreas:happen on this level of, let's say, mystical philosophical experience.
Andreas:It also happens on this very practical level.
Andreas:Okay, now I know what I have to do right now.
Andreas:So it happens on the level of community, of the, in the level of relation,
Andreas:which again, is an expression of the profound, the profound luminous oneness.
Andreas:We, we are, we are part of, we we are here to nourish.
Andreas:Yeah.
Andreas:So that's, that's how I, I would describe this today probably the,
Andreas:the, the passage you read, but I, I started from the, from the end.
Andreas:So maybe, uh, okay, let me, let me, let me think.
Andreas:I wanted to, if I wanted to, yeah, so I, I, I'd become a bit more, a bit
Andreas:broader in, in my, in my idea of what, what, what is actually the profound
Andreas:experience in meeting otherness.
Andreas:And I'd say, and I, I think I said this already, I'd say that if we, we are unable
Andreas:to understand that it is life in which we participate, then, then it, it will
Andreas:vanish, it will drop through our fingers.
Andreas:And, and at, you know, that's actually today, I would say the
Andreas:problem is that in, in doing so, we can, we cannot be, we stop being.
Andreas:We stop being fertile ourselves.
Andreas:We stop, we, we, we stop being, we stop giving the gift of life.
Andreas:That's the problem.
Andreas:No, I, you see, I wouldn't say, okay, and then if we don't understand
Andreas:it, then we'll, we'll, we'll die.
Andreas:, that would be too simple.
Andreas:in my, in my, in my, and, um, the, the profound problem is that we, we
Andreas:stop, we, we somehow pull ourselves out of this divine circle of, of gifting
Andreas:life because we have been given life.
Andreas:And that's terrible.
Andreas:That's really terrible.
Andreas:Yes.
Andreas:And that's what we are doing.
Andreas:That's like what even our philosophy told, tells us.
Andreas:And the, the ideology behind capitalism says that don't ever give anything.
Andreas:Be, be egoistic.
Andreas:And it's absolutely terrible because it is.
Andreas:If you, if you wish, it is anti cosmic . And, and I mean,
Andreas:it, it, this really hurts.
Andreas:It's somehow blessed for me.
Andreas:Maybe you what could go in this direction, but it really, really hurts.
Andreas:Like, you know, it, it hurts.
Andreas:Like if there's somebody who, who is truly giving soul and wants you
Andreas:to take his or her gift and you, you slap him into the, in the face.
Andreas:Because, because you feel so much, so superior, you see this is really hurting.
Andreas:This is really, really profoundly wrong.
Andreas:And it somehow, it, somehow, it goes against the, the whole grain
Andreas:of, of the whole project of life.
Andreas:And this is, this is why it is so terrible.
Andreas:It is so profoundly terrible.
Andreas:And, and our civilization is so deeply caught in this, that this,
Andreas:that it can't survive, can't survive if it, it works like this because
Andreas:it's so absolutely outlandish.
Andreas:This attitude.
Andreas:It, it cannot be allowed . It just cannot be allowed.
Kate:It calls to mind for me that in a biological system of isolation,
Kate:that cancer is a disease of isolation.
Kate:Right?
Kate:It is a mm-hmm.
Kate:, it is a cell that can no longer communicate with the whole.
Kate:And for us to remove ourselves from the cycle, as it were, to remove ourselves
Kate:from this recursive and eternal act of reciprocity in isolation and to not give
Kate:back in, in, I mean in, in the beautiful metaphor that you put in with eating.
Kate:You know, this, this act of, um, one of my favorite definitions of intimacy
Kate:is a union of particles, right?
Kate:And so, so eating is, is coming home to self and becoming other
Kate:and giving all at the same time.
Kate:Yeah, yeah.
Kate:In this metabolic act.
Andreas:Yeah.
Andreas:Yeah.
Andreas:That you put it very well.
Andreas:Yeah.
Andreas:Yeah.
Andreas:Yeah.
Andreas:That's, I I like to, I like this.
Andreas:Yes.
Andreas:But you were going somewhere.
Kate:Yeah.
Kate:Good.
Kate:Yeah.
Kate:I was just going to, to remove ourself from that cycle and, and to really
Kate:distill what you said and, and, and put emphasis on it is, it is worth than death.
Kate:Death is a, a part of that cycle.
Kate:But to see ourselves as being outside of or above that cycle mm-hmm.
Kate:I think that the ramifications of that are something that we
Kate:are, uh, we, that we are living.
Andreas:Yeah.
Andreas:Yeah.
Andreas:It's interesting.
Andreas:I mean, it's interesting to, to, to think in the direction of hierarchy of horrors.
Andreas:So it's, it's not even, it's not even, this attitude means not
Andreas:even to be, to be, to be a killer.
Andreas:It means to be somebody who actively suppresses the idea and the, the practice
Andreas:that the, the reality is giving life.
Andreas:So, and giving life is actually giving a gift.
Andreas:I mean, this is, I I, I always arrive at this point that somebody who,
Andreas:who, who, who is, who is presented with the most precious gift in all
Andreas:innocence, reacts with disdain and violence towards the one who gives this.
Andreas:And he, he forsaken all possibilities of future existence.
Andreas:Because he, he, with this, he steps out of reality.
Andreas:And, um, so this is, that's the level which, which we are witnessing.
Andreas:Um, it's, it's incredible.
Andreas:I mean, it's, for me, one of the biggest enigmas actually, actually is why,
Andreas:why did this thinking gain ground?
Andreas:What happened?
Andreas:What happened?
Andreas:Because we know people that people who were living in, in more life
Andreas:centered cultures, although they might live on, on materially very
Andreas:difficult terms, they, they're empirically, they're always happier.
Andreas:You have all these empirical, psychological and investigations
Andreas:which show that those people are just, just like empirically happier
Andreas:if you grew up in such a culture.
Andreas:And I mean, we're not talking about depression and, and despair because they
Andreas:are colonized and decimated and destroyed.
Andreas:So that's an, that's on another page.
Andreas:But just if you live in this so sort of culture, you're, you
Andreas:live a good life because you live life, you are part of life.
Andreas:And then people somehow decided, let's stop that.
Andreas:We have something better . We have, we have permanence, individual permanence.
Andreas:We want individual permanence fortified by possessions.
Andreas:It's a very strange that this happened.
Kate:I think about a lot the.
Kate:When this happened or the process of it happening, because I don't
Kate:think it happened and one fell swoop.
Kate:I think that there were little fractures in, in this throughout time,
Kate:and I wonder if in many ways it's sort of like, I don't know if you're
Kate:familiar with Gabo, but, but his work in intergenerational trauma mm-hmm.
Kate:And so that this, this viewpoint as it begins to fracture within society and, and
Kate:become more pervasive is then inherited.
Kate:And just like we lose a skill in generations, so we lose a skill of
Kate:gathering or of recognizing different plant species or whatever that is,
Kate:that skill becomes lost in time.
Kate:The skill of knowing mm-hmm.
Kate:Our place in the interconnected web of
Andreas:life.
Andreas:Mm-hmm.
Andreas:Yeah.
Andreas:I think the, the term trauma, trauma is very helpful to understand and, and it's,
Andreas:it's very helpful to see the society we are part of as profoundly traumatized
Andreas:as, as a trauma generating society.
Andreas:And, um, so maybe it's, it, it was enough to start trauma by one huge violent action
Andreas:and then generating many traumatized people who started to be violent.
Andreas:Towards others.
Andreas:Maybe it's possible because trauma tr tries to fortify itself.
Andreas:Cause the, the, the source, the roots of trauma become untouchable
Andreas:because they're so painful.
Andreas:So they need to be hidden because they're hidden.
Andreas:You'll, you'll be violent to others and there will be traumatized.
Andreas:I mean, government describes this very well as to others.
Andreas:And, and we can, we, we look back on 10,000 years of trauma history in Quest.
Andreas:Yes.
Andreas:And, um, yeah, that's true.
Andreas:And it's, this is one of the reasons it is so difficult or impossible to,
Andreas:to, to get out of this because there's an, there's a sort of natural block,
Andreas:which, which, which prevents trauma to be dissolved because it's so painful.
Andreas:And, and it's, it's very, so it's, you know, this, this, this strange enigma to
Andreas:see a whole society, a whole civilization march into the direction of doom and
Andreas:further future historians, if there, there will be this profession , um,
Andreas:anymore, they, they will kind of ask them, well, why could they do this?
Andreas:, it was so obvious.
Andreas:But then in, in profoundly traumatized, um, communities, people behave deadly.
Andreas:Or although they know.
Andreas:I think that's, it's a, it's a good perspective.
Andreas:Changes very much.
Andreas:And you see many, many people, many hopeful, beautiful people trying to
Andreas:work for mitigation of, of the worst or prevention of collapse, whatever.
Andreas:They still appeal to rational faculties, which, which don't work if you, if you
Andreas:have to collaborate with traumatized people, you cannot just tell them what
Andreas:is the right thing to do because they won't do it cuz they're, they're, they're
Andreas:guided by other forces which are, which are much deeper and much more powerful.
Andreas:It's a little bit like this, but I, I, I cannot really, um, as we're,
Andreas:we're at that point of like what to do, I cannot offer you any working
Andreas:alternative apart from what Spinoza says, orient yourself towards life.
Andreas:And, and I mean this works on a, on a, on on, on the individual
Andreas:level and can work on many on the, on the level of many individuals.
Andreas:And, um, it always makes sense.
Andreas:Whatever the outcome, cuz that's, that's the, that's the vector, that's the
Andreas:desire of the reality is to give life.
Andreas:So if you do that, you're, you're good.
Andreas:in a way.
Andreas:. Kate: I love this.
Andreas:I love this because then.
Andreas:Because then I think we reenter the cycle of, of surrendering
Andreas:ourselves to be transformed.
Andreas:Yeah.
Andreas:Yeah.
Andreas:That when we go back to being in service of life, then yeah.
Andreas:We have reentered that cycle.
Andreas:Yes.
Andreas:And I mean it's, it's, it becomes much smaller than thinking of how
Andreas:to solve, how to save the planet.
Andreas:You know?
Andreas:That was, that was for long, for long years.
Andreas:That was a professional, like, yeah, I'm trying to save the planet, which,
Andreas:which, which was actually infected by the same hubris of, of those who were,
Andreas:weren't trying to save the planet, but who were trying to save their portfolios.
Andreas:The same hubris of, of being able to master forces, which are absolutely
Andreas:beyond our, our, our power.
Andreas:It's, it's, it's somehow infected by the same thing, but
Andreas:it, so it can be much smaller.
Andreas:Only that if it's much smaller, you, you need to follow through the whole
Andreas:beautiful thought of Spinoza, which means that you, you're not even
Andreas:interested in the least bit in death.
Andreas:That doesn't concern you at all because you're in service of life and in practice
Andreas:that's, it's quite a bit to chew on.
Andreas:, as we all know.
Andreas:, Kate: it's a big cookie.
Andreas:Yeah, it's a big cookie.
Andreas:Well, it's bigger than most of the cookies in this bag.
Andreas:Yeah.
Andreas:Actually, yes.
Andreas:But it's very nourishing, you know?
Andreas:Hmm.
Andreas:. Mm-hmm.
Andreas:. Very nourishing.
Andreas:Yeah.
Andreas:Yeah.
Kate:I love that as a space to begin to, I don't, I don't want
Kate:for, for both of us to turn into pumpkins at the two hour mark.
Andreas:Um, yeah, how do I look?
Andreas:There's some, there's some light reflected
Kate:slowly becoming
Andreas:pumpkin, but we can, we can prepare for, for fold back
Andreas:the chairs and the, the tables and, and the preparing the dissent
Kate:Preparing the dissent.
Kate:But I can't, I can't let go of the invisible dimension.
Kate:I would be remiss if I were to let go of where moving from embodied matter
Kate:and into the invisible dimension, which, you know, called for me that
Kate:we are as much, you know, we are more empty space than we are solid matter.
Kate:And I just wonder if you might touch on, on the invisible dimension
Kate:and where that's taking you.
Andreas:Is that a prepared question or is it a follow up
Andreas:to, to something I said before?
Andreas:It
Kate:is a follow up to something that you said before.
Andreas:Okay.
Andreas:Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Andreas:Well, um,
Andreas:how can I, how can I put this?
Andreas:So, so there's a, there's a term I introduced some years ago to,
Andreas:in order to describe that hole, which has this, this embodied.
Andreas:Aspect, and it has this invisible, I palpable un nons
Andreas:spatial non temporal aspect.
Andreas:And my term for that is poetic space.
Andreas:Poetic because it is always generative.
Andreas:And because understanding in it is always done in, in, in a poetic way.
Andreas:So that means through, through participating in,
Andreas:in the creativity of life.
Andreas:Or you could say in terms of we have, we have been saying before through,
Andreas:through giving the gift of life.
Andreas:So that's, that's, I call that poetic space.
Andreas:And the, the idea in that is that it is actually, it is not as
Andreas:ucli space, it's not a 3D space.
Andreas:It is a, a space of the potential of life of which most lies hidden to any
Andreas:forms of material embodied senses.
Andreas:But we still access it and, and we are in it.
Andreas:Um, when, when I, I've been talking about the, the profound experience
Andreas:of our own being here and being this all, and we spoke about that, what the
Andreas:Sufi is called the heart of hearts.
Andreas:We are in the center of this poetic space.
Andreas:So we, we exist on this invisible plane all the time,
Andreas:and all others exist on this.
Andreas:Let's say in the, in the same.
Andreas:It's, it's, it has the same reality as our bodily existence has.
Andreas:Only that we, we, um, have nearly completely forgotten about it.
Andreas:Um, but, but you can go there, you can go there in various ways.
Andreas:You can go there by, by somehow stepping out of your, in individuality, in,
Andreas:in, in allowing yourself to be just sitting with your own aliveness, which
Andreas:works after some training that, that would be called the mystical path.
Andreas:And you can also go there by acting, by what I've been calling
Andreas:this talk, but being in service.
Andreas:So you can, it's, it's also pragmatic thing.
Andreas:It's, it's something which, which isn't material, but which
Andreas:will let sprout materiality.
Andreas:So it's, it's, it, it, it will invite, um, being somehow, um, from the
Andreas:invisible side into the visible side, and you can also communicate on that.
Andreas:So in a way, it's, in a way this poetic space is very similar, I think, to, to,
Andreas:um, what, um, Buddhists call the ground or the, the, the luminous emptiness.
Andreas:It's, it's a nice thing to realize that we are there and
Andreas:that this luminous emptiness.
Andreas:Has the,
Andreas:how can I call it?
Andreas:Has the, the, the, the, its center is the desire to give life.
Andreas:You see, that's, it's very invisible because it's, uh, it's just the desire.
Andreas:It's totally invisible and it's absolutely indestructible.
Andreas:So that's the, the root.
Andreas:And if you follow this, you, if you make yourself a tool
Andreas:of this, then you create life.
Andreas:Life will come into being, life will multiply, life will manifest.
Andreas:And it is the experience of being alive as well, which again, is in, is invisible.
Andreas:It's only in inside of yourself, but it's also contagious.
Andreas:So you see, it's, this invisible space is continuously pouring into visibility.
Andreas:And even if we mess it up totally as humanity, what we are currently doing,
Andreas:we, we, we, it will, it won't change.
Andreas:It will still pour into reality.
Andreas:There's a, another quotation from second century Nagarjuna, the Buddhist sage.
Andreas:It says, when all Buddhas have died, Enlightenment will burst
Andreas:into being from emptiness, you see?
Andreas:So that he said, I think the same thing.
Andreas:So it's this, it's absolutely indestructible.
Andreas:And that that is so, isn't that beautiful?
Andreas:I mean, that's the source which feeds us, and that's the source
Andreas:from which we feed others.
Andreas:And it, it cannot go away cuz its character is that it cannot go away.
Andreas:You see?
Andreas:Isn't that, isn't that nice?
Andreas:I mean, isn't that pretty?
Andreas:I really like it, but it's, you see, it, it, I that you, you won't go and find
Andreas:it somewhere under a tree, although you, you might find it somewhere under a tree.
Andreas:You see?
Andreas:You might find a source under a tree from which clear water
Andreas:comes and then you've found it.
Andreas:, you've also found it because it has transcended that invisibility
Andreas:into the space of bodies.
Andreas:And my my experience is that it is very important how we are be
Andreas:behaving in this invisible space.
Andreas:And it's, it's a place where we can do a lot with the right attitude and which has
Andreas:been completely neglected by our culture.
Andreas:And, um, the, all the rituals in all the cultures are actually working with
Andreas:this invisible space which gives life.
Andreas:So they, all the rituals are tailored to, to make this source being benevolent
Andreas:and, um, cooperative and welcoming it into, into all human endeavors.
Andreas:And Western people normally don't do this.
Andreas:They don't even know that this exists.
Andreas:Something.
Andreas:Okay, let's, let's try, let's look at u some YouTube videos about manifesting
Andreas:and then I can have some more stuff.
Andreas:So, so it's, it's very naive and very, very, very istic, but it's very important
Andreas:to, to, to, to behave well and to be, um, to be welcoming of life on this level.
Andreas:And, and I think that's also something we could do and we should do.
Andreas:And I think it, it will, it will do a lot because it aligns yourself to
Andreas:your work in service of a aliveness.
Andreas:And, um, it's something which to, to western ears really might,
Andreas:will sound weird and strange.
Andreas:I think.
Andreas:Um, this suggestion that we need to go there and be active there
Andreas:in a be benevolent way, but.
Andreas:It's something, cultures which are much wiser than ours have always been doing.
Andreas:That's, that's, that was there, there, the main occupation that was even, you
Andreas:know, that was even the many cultures, that's even the idea of, of the role
Andreas:of humans in this society of being.
Andreas:They, they can do this work.
Andreas:Mm-hmm.
Andreas:They can care for life on the one hand, by, by, by being, by kindling life in
Andreas:the ecosystem, by being fair partners to other beings in the ecosystem.
Andreas:So that would be your job that the stewarding job.
Andreas:And on the other hand, by calling for abundance on the invisible
Andreas:side, these two roles were always, they were absolutely inseparable.
Andreas:So that was in, if you, if you look at how cultures understand the,
Andreas:the role of humans, it's that role.
Andreas:So you see, they, we are, we are not the, the boss, we are not the
Andreas:one who knows better, but we are the ones who are most called to be in
Andreas:service and on, on these two planes.
Andreas:And I'd say it's, it's, it's this, it's something important
Andreas:to, to start this service.
Andreas:If you are, if, if you are like me, somebody is, Strange from that because we
Andreas:have been grown up in a western system, find our way back to this nourishing
Andreas:work on the invisible dimension.
Andreas:It's really, really important.
Kate:Thank you very much for elucidating that.
Kate:And I think , I think that actually in many ways brought us to a really
Kate:beautiful place of coming back to the idea of being in service and, and part
Kate:of our role here and to give people Yeah.
Kate:A, a sort of tangible effort at the end of Yeah, this conversation.
Andreas:And you, you know, just when you said part of our role here, you
Andreas:know, people are always, no, normally people are happy when they have a role,
Andreas:which is, which is actually denying and helpful and, and stewarding.
Andreas:And this, it's all, this is a statistic thing.
Andreas:You look at surveys, people are happy when they have a meaningful
Andreas:role in the living hall.
Andreas:You know, it's very easy.
Andreas:They, we, we, we don't know.
Andreas:We don't need all these things.
Andreas:We only need them because our neighbor, our friends have more of these things.
Andreas:So we also need some of these things.
Andreas:And, but in the end, it's, it's, people are happy when they, when
Andreas:they feel they are alive and they feel they contribute to life.
Andreas:That's actually, we are made for this.
Andreas:So it's, it's crazily simple.
Andreas:And we're, we are somehow straight from that a little bit.
Andreas:It's, it's simple.
Andreas:It's actually simple.
Andreas:Yeah.
Andreas:Okay.
Andreas:One minute before pumpkin time.
Andreas:We, we, one
Kate:minute before pumpkin time.
Kate:We're right there.
Kate:We're right at, at at midnight.
Kate:Um, thank you, thank you for, for all of this.
Kate:And I, I'm just so appreciative of your work and I, it, it, it is so beautiful.
Kate:I don't really know how to mirror back to you what this has meant in my own journey
Kate:towards stewardship, towards aliveness, towards cooperation and inter beingness.
Kate:And I Yeah.
Kate:Thanks.
Kate:Yes.
Kate:Think that so many of the threads w we tug on here, on this podcast, you have
Kate:put into words in a, in a way that I feel like I am often just dancing around.
Kate:And so thank you for bringing that matter forth.
Kate:Uh, you know, towards the end as you were speaking, I thought
Kate:about the singularities with these points of, of seeming smallness
Kate:or nothingness or invisibleness from which everything comes forth.
Kate:And, uh, whether it's the Big Bang or it's a seed in the soil, or it's
Kate:a, a person inviting more aliveness.
Kate:Into this traumatic time here on earth.
Kate:And so I am, I'm very grateful for your work.
Andreas:Yeah, thank you.
Andreas:No, thanks.
Andreas:That's, that's, um, to me, that's the experience of, um,
Andreas:shared aliveness, so very good.
Andreas:And, um, thanks for the, for this, the, the poetic space you
Andreas:offered here in the last two hours.
Andreas:Yeah,
Kate:yeah.
Kate:Where can I send, where can people find you?
Kate:I will have links to all of your work,
Andreas:but Yeah.
Andreas:Well, , where can people find you, sounds like from tomorrow?
Andreas:Cue in front of my door.
Andreas:I need to have to jump out at the window.
Andreas:. No, I mean you, you probably, if you have did some re if you did some research.
Andreas:So what, what would be helpful actually?
Andreas:What, what would you need?
Andreas:Like, um, my, you'll probably have my English language website and
Andreas:Yes, and I mean, it's, if you, there will be some books, so if people are
Andreas:interested and there's the, have, have you, have you taken the Avaya
Andreas:course I gave before Christmas?
Andreas:No, because, because that's also because it is very much, very
Andreas:much my work right now to explore this, this invisible dimension.
Andreas:So it, it was, um, Somewhat familiar.
Andreas:The, the climate I've, I've been teaching.
Andreas:So I'll, I'll send you so you people can still get it.
Andreas:So it's still there only in, in recorded form.
Andreas:So I'll send you this as well.
Andreas:I can think a little bit about some more links, whatever to, to, to send to you.
Andreas:Yeah.
Andreas:So if there's anything you'd really you need in concrete terms,
Andreas:tell me I, I try to find it.
Kate:No, I can, I can link to all of this and, and the course especially,
Kate:it's something that I'll dive into as
Andreas:well.
Andreas:Send you the course sent, send you the course because I was actually
Andreas:really happy how it went and I think the participants were as well.
Andreas:And it's so, it, it was really centering about these, these topics
Andreas:and doing, also doing some in inner invisible dimension work somehow
Andreas:and, um, sitting together online.
Andreas:But it works well.
Andreas:Yeah.
Andreas:So, okay, so I'll, let me somehow, let me write it on this sheet of paper.
Kate:I can also, sorry, I can also remind you via email remind if you don't
Andreas:wanna write anything already realized.
Andreas:I'm, I'm, cause I'm, I'm somehow, um, a bad rememberer . I try to not
Andreas:at remember only the most urgent things and well my website for sure.
Andreas:Yep.
Andreas:And I have that I go to, I'm going to do, um, And onsite
Andreas:course in Italy in early fall.
Andreas:Mm.
Andreas:So, let's see.
Andreas:I'm, I somehow hesitated to do this because it's a lot of organization, but I,
Andreas:I think I'll going, I'm going to do this.
Andreas:So that will be on that, that website if somebody wants to deepen this.
Andreas:Okay.
Andreas:If anything you feel anything is missing, then tell me Sure.
Andreas:That
Kate:I will, I will.
Kate:Um, Thank you so much.
Kate:Thank you so much for
Andreas:listening to this episode of The Mind, body and Soil Podcast.
Kate:If what you found resonated with you, may I ask that you
Kate:share it with your friends or
Andreas:leave us a rating and review wherever you listen to podcasts.
Andreas:This act of reciprocity
Kate:helps others find mind, body, and soil.
Kate:If you're looking for more,
Andreas:you can find
Kate:us@groundworkcollective.com and at Kate underscore
Andreas:Kavanaugh.
Andreas:That's k a t e underscore K A V A N A U
Kate:G H On Instagram.
Kate:I would like to give a very special thank you to China and Seth Kent of the
Kate:band, allright Allright for the clips from their beautiful song over the
Kate:Edge from their album, the Crucible.
Kate:You can find them at Allright allright on Instagram and